How to use comments vs notes in Google Sheets & Excel

Below are practical ways to manage comments vs notes in Google Sheets and Excel, from hands-on to fully automated with AI agents.

1. Manual methods in Google Sheets and Excel

‍

A. Google Sheets – using comments for conversations

1. Open your sheet and select the cell with data you want to discuss.
2. Right‑click the cell and choose Comment, or use the menu: Insert → Comment.
3. Type your question, decision, or request (treat this like a mini chat thread).
4. Click Comment to post. Teammates can reply in the same thread.
5. Use the comments button in the top‑right to see all open threads and resolve them when a decision is made.

Official help: https://support.google.com/docs/answer/65129

‍

B. Google Sheets – using notes for quiet context

1. Select the cell whose logic or source you want to document.
2. Right‑click → Insert note.
3. Add background info: formula explanation, data source URL, owner, or refresh cadence.
4. Hover the cell to read the note; it won’t trigger notifications or threaded replies.

Notes guidance is included in: https://support.google.com/docs/answer/3093331

‍

C. Excel – threaded comments for collaboration

1. In Excel (Microsoft 365), select the cell.
2. Go to Review → New Comment or right‑click → New Comment.
3. Type your message; use @mentions for teammates if available in your tenant.
4. Teammates reply in the same thread; you can Resolve the thread once done.
5. Use Review → Show Comments to open the side pane and navigate all threads.

Official help: https://support.microsoft.com/en-us/office/the-difference-between-threaded-comments-and-notes-75a51eec-4092-42ab-abf8-7669077b7be3

‍

D. Excel – notes for annotations (legacy style)

1. Select a cell, go to Review → Notes → New Note, or right‑click → New Note.
2. Type the explanation, assumptions, or reminder.
3. Resize and format the note as needed.
4. Use Review → Notes → Show All Notes to scan all annotations.

‍

E. Converting between comments and notes in Excel (cleanup pass)

1. Open the workbook and go to the Review tab.
2. To turn a static note into a comment, choose the cell → Review → Notes → Convert to Comment.
3. To simplify an old discussion into a note, choose the cell → Review → Notes → Convert to Note.
4. Use this to standardize: decisions and questions live in comments; documentation lives in notes.

More detail: https://support.microsoft.com/en-us/office/insert-comments-and-notes-in-excel-3c9a7d3b-6ce1-4b94-83e1-5aca0741e73b

Pros of manual methods

• Full control over tone and structure.
• No setup cost; uses built‑in features.
• Great for small teams or low‑volume sheets.

Cons

• Easy to get inconsistent: people mix comments and notes.
• Hard to audit across many files or months of history.
• Time‑consuming to clean up when onboarding new staff.

‍

2. No‑code automation with tools

Here you keep humans in charge of content but automate triggers around comments and notes.

‍

A. Trigger workflows from Google Sheets comments (Zapier/Make)

1. Use Zapier or Make and connect your Google account.
2. Create a trigger like New or updated comment in Google Sheets (or, if not available, trigger on New row and use a dedicated “Needs review” column instead of comments).
3. Add actions:
   • Post the comment text into Slack or Microsoft Teams.
   • Create a task in Asana/ClickUp with a link to the exact cell.
   • Append the comment into a running “decision log” spreadsheet.
4. Use filters to react only to comments containing tags such as “[BLOCKER]” or a specific label.

‍

B. Capture “note‑like” context as structured fields

1. In Sheets or Excel, add helper columns: e.g., Assumption, Owner, Next review date.
2. In your no‑code tool, trigger on New or updated row.
3. When those fields are filled, automatically:
   • Add a standardized note to the cell using the API (Excel via Microsoft Graph / Office Scripts; Sheets via Google Sheets API wrapped by Zapier/Make).
   • Or send a summary email to stakeholders containing the new context.

‍

C. Excel + Power Automate for comment hygiene

1. Store your workbook in OneDrive or SharePoint.
2. In Power Automate, create a flow triggered by When a file is created or modified (properties only).
3. Add an Office Scripts or Graph API action that:
   • Scans for comments older than X days marked “Resolved”.
   • Exports them to a log sheet.
   • Optionally deletes the resolved threads to keep the workbook light.
4. Schedule the flow daily.

Pros of no‑code methods

• Reduce manual follow‑up; comments become live signals.
• Centralize decisions into CRMs, PM tools, or logs.
• Still transparent and easy to tweak.

Cons

• Logic is brittle if sheet structure changes.
• No semantic understanding of text—just triggers on patterns.
• Hard to scale across dozens of workbooks without careful design.

‍

3. Scaling with AI computer agents (Simular‑style workflows)

Now imagine an AI computer agent that can operate your entire desktop, browser, and cloud stack like a power user.

‍

A. Agent to normalize comments vs notes across files

• You define the playbook: "In Google Sheets and Excel, move decisions/questions into comments; move background explanations into notes."
• The AI agent:
  1. Opens each assigned spreadsheet (Excel desktop or web, Google Sheets in Chrome).
  2. Scans cells, existing comments, and notes.
  3. Classifies text: decision, question, reminder, formula explanation, data source, etc.
  4. Converts mis‑used comments into notes (and vice versa) following your rules.
  5. Logs every change in a summary sheet for audit.

Pros

• Semantic understanding: it actually reads content, not just triggers.
• Works across tools (Sheets + Excel in same run).
• Huge time savings when retrofitting old workbooks.

Cons

• Requires an initial spec and small pilot run.
• Best suited for recurring cleanup (weekly/monthly) rather than one‑off tiny files.

‍

B. Agent as ongoing “spreadsheet editor” for revenue teams

• Sales leaders often want consistent comment formats on pipeline or forecast sheets.
• You teach the agent a pattern: "Each deal row must have: latest call summary in a note, open questions as comments, and a resolved comment once next step is agreed."
• On a schedule, the agent:
  1. Opens CRM export sheets in Google Sheets.
  2. Reads free‑text cells and existing comments.
  3. Suggests or auto‑creates structured notes (e.g., "Source: LinkedIn", "Next review: 2025‑04‑01").
  4. Moves outdated threads to a summary sheet and closes them as resolved comments.

‍

C. Agent to sync insights between Excel and Google Sheets

• Many agencies keep client‑facing Sheets and internal Excel models.
• The AI agent:
  1. Reads comments in the internal Excel model where strategists discuss performance.
  2. Distills non‑sensitive conclusions into concise notes in the client Google Sheet.
  3. Ensures client sheets stay clean (notes only), while internal debates stay in Excel comments.

Overall pros of AI agents

• Production‑grade: can handle workflows with thousands of steps.
• Transparent: every action is inspectable and repeatable.
• Frees humans to focus on strategy, not formatting.

Overall cons

• Needs clear guardrails and testing.
• Overkill for very small teams with one or two sheets.