How To Turn LinkedIn Comments Into Warm Leads Guide

From Comment To Conversation: Your Options

Think of every comment on your LinkedIn post as someone stepping up after a talk and saying, “That resonated.” The only question is: do you have the time (and consistency) to talk to all of them?

‍

Below are the top ways to contact people who comment on your LinkedIn posts — from fully manual to fully automated with an AI computer agent.

‍

1. The Purely Manual Way (High Quality, Low Scale)

1. Open your LinkedIn post.
2. Reply to each comment publicly.
3. Click into the commenter’s profile.
4. Read their headline, About, and recent posts.
5. Send a personalized DM or connection request referencing their comment.

‍

Pros:

• Deepest context and most human.
• Great for high-ticket, low-volume offers.

Cons:

• Painfully slow once you get 30, 50, 100+ comments.
• Easy to miss people and forget follow ups.

‍

2. Semi-Manual With A Simple Tracker

1. Copy the post link and open it in a browser tab.
2. Manually list commenters in a Google Sheet (name, URL, comment, status).
3. Work through the sheet row by row: visit profile, send DM, mark as “Contacted / Replied / Booked call”.

‍

Pros:

• Still personal, but more organized.
• Gives you a simple pipeline view for agencies and small teams.

Cons:

• Still a lot of copying, clicking, and context switching.
• Follow-up sequences depend on your memory.

‍

3. Tool-Assisted Export + Messaging

If you’re comfortable with growth tools, you can:

1. Export commenters from your LinkedIn post into a CSV or sheet using a data collection tool.
2. Clean the list (remove competitors, irrelevant roles, or spam).
3. Use templates in a messaging tool or CRM to semi-personalize first-touch DMs or emails.

‍

Pros:

• Good for lead generation campaigns.
• Faster first touch; still room to add personalization tokens.

Cons:

• Easy to drift into spammy territory if you’re not careful.
• You’re still managing several tools and workflows.

‍

4. Fully Automated With An AI Computer Agent (Simular)

Here’s where things get interesting for busy founders, agencies, and sales teams.

‍

With a Simular AI computer agent, you can:

• Open LinkedIn in a browser.
• Navigate to your post.
• Collect all commenters and their profile links into a Google Sheet.
• Filter by role, industry, or keywords.
• Draft tailored reply comments and DMs based on their text.
• Send or schedule those messages — all without writing brittle scripts.

‍

Because Simular agents operate like a real user on your desktop and browser, you can see every action they take, review drafts, and tweak your playbook without touching code.

‍

Pros:

• True scale: hundreds or thousands of comments handled with production-grade reliability.
• Transparent execution: you can inspect and edit any step.
• Frees you to focus on actual calls, deals, and content.

Cons:

• Requires an initial setup and “training” phase.
• You still need to design good messaging strategies.

‍

5. Hybrid: You Lead, The Agent Does The Busywork

The sweet spot for most knowledge workers is hybrid:

• You write 3–5 authentic message frameworks.
• The Simular agent pulls in each person’s comment and profile context.
• It assembles a personalized reply or DM.
• You review the first batch, then let it run for future posts.

‍

You stay in control of the tone and relationships, while the agent handles the copy‑paste, filtering, and late‑night outreach. That’s how you turn comment sections into a living, breathing pipeline — without sacrificing your calendar.

‍